Encouragement

PUBLIC_FLAG_#{@journal.pf_int} RSS feed of hiralingual's latest journal entries Aug 19th 2010 10:33

I have a question about the preposition by. Are there any correct sentences below?


(a) We can encourage each other by music.

(b) We can encourage each other by word.

(c) We can encourage each other by words.

(d) We can encourage each other by love.

(e) We can encourage each other by winks.

(f) We can encourage each other by gift exchange.

Thanks a lot!
Aug 19th 2010 11:00 Like a Leaf

To a native American English speaker, all of these sentences sound a little strange, even if they may be grammatically correct (I'm not 100% sure). If I were to rephrase the sentences so they sound less awkward, I would say:
(a) We can encourage each other using music.
(b) I can't quite rephrase this one to sound right.
(c) We can encourage each other through words.
(d) We can encourage each other with love.
(e) We can encourage each other with winks.
(f) We can encourage each other via gift exchange.
Aug 19th 2010 11:35 tony

  • (f) We can encourage each other by gift exchange.
  • (f) We can encourage each other by exchanging gifts. [Alternative: We can encourage each other with gifts.]

 
As in the correction I gave for (f), all of these will sound more natural if you complete the sentence with a verb phrase rather than with a noun phrase. The preposition before a noun phrase is more likely to be "with" than "by."
Aug 19th 2010 22:16 hiralingual

Thank you very much! "By" is sounding more and more interesting to me. It might make for the next topic I do research on.
Aug 20th 2010 18:01 chequer

I think you would have to use the preposition "with" for all of these.

If you changed it to:

We were encouraged by the music, by the words, by the gifts.....

but the article is not optional in those implying that we are reporting on the effect of particular things not just things in general.

The other option is to use the -ing form after by:

We can encourage each other by winking
We can encourage each other by exchanging gifts

But that doesn't work for all the examples you give.

Journals Statistics

Latest entry

See more >>

Latest comments

See more >>

Entries by Month