As Popular Among Children

PUBLIC_FLAG_#{@journal.pf_int} RSS feed of M-K-G's latest journal entries Nov 22nd 2011 02:59 word-order-selection
(A) It seems that baseball is not as popular as it was among children.
(B) It seems that baseball is not as popular among children as it was.

Do you think both word-orders are correct?
Nov 22nd 2011 03:05 r.fLowers

(B) sounds better than (A). It feels like (A) is missing a word. I would word (A) like this: "It seems that baseball is not as popular as it once was among children."
Nov 22nd 2011 03:36 Mike
I agree with this answer^

Another way to say it is:
It seems that baseball is not as popular among children as it used to be.
Nov 22nd 2011 03:56 マット 

A) is stating that children liked baseball more then who ever you are talking about.. because you say the words "is not AS popular as it was ammong children"
B) is stating that baseball is no longer that popular among children.. as in they used to like it much more in the past.

both sentences are well worded and make sense but they have different meanings
Nov 22nd 2011 04:05

  • (A) It seems that baseball is not as popular as it was among children.
  • (A) It seems that baseball is not as popular as it was is among children.

 

  • (B) It seems that baseball is not as popular among children as it was.
  • (B) It seems that baseball is not as popular among children as it was as it used to be.

 
Yeh both fine, I just tied them up a little :)

Journals Statistics

Latest entry

See more >>

Latest comments

See more >>

Entries by Month