します、しています、しました。。。

PUBLIC_FLAG_#{@journal.pf_int} RSS feed of drfranktm's latest journal entries Jan 18th 2011 11:57
I have a question, mostly regarding the first two. The third one is clearly past tense, but I'm a little fuzzy on the first two.

しています is like the present progressive in English, right? "I am doing..."

And します is like the simple present? "I do..." For example: On Friday, I do [something]. => 金曜日に[something]をします。

Am I getting this right or is it something else? Thanks in advance!
Jan 18th 2011 12:33 nao

しています=ing
します=will(future)
This is easy explanation.
If it is not easy to understand, I'm sorry.
Jan 18th 2011 12:35 yinamoto

しています is basically the same with (as?) the present progressive in English, as you said. But it sometimes used to express a state:

今、彼はゴルフをしています。[He is playing golf now. A present progressive]
彼はおとなしくしています。[He stays quiet. Expressing a state]

します is used for the simple present and for a future form:

金曜日にはいつもゴルフをします。[I play golf on every Friday. A simple present]
これからゴルフをします。[I'm going to play golf from now. A future form]
Jan 18th 2011 13:12 drfranktm
I would say "the same as".

Thanks for your explanation. I think I get it now. :-)
Jan 18th 2011 12:46 Seech

します is an action incompleted.
しています is also an action incompleted but continues for a while.
These two are used in the presend and in the future.

Let's change these into the past tense.
本を読んだ: j'ai lu un livre.
本を読んでいた。: je lisais un livre.
Jan 18th 2011 12:52 美璃

  • "I am doing..."
  • "I am doing..."I have been doing( something)......it is not just "doing" It means you're still have been..

 

  • And します is like the simple present?
  • And します is like the simple present?I think します is should be future tense, because it means you're going to do something in the future or from now on.

 
します、やります、来ます
These are grammatically must be future tense but we often use them like to do something just NOW.That's why it makes you a bit confused.
Jan 18th 2011 13:14 drfranktm

I think I more or less get it now. Many thanks to everyone for your explanations! :D

Journals Statistics

Latest entry

See more >>

Latest comments

See more >>

Entries by Month